| Brand | Score | More info |
| 1. Nutro Cat Food | 95% | Read Review |
| 2. Merrick Cat Food | 93% | Read Review |
| 3. Weruva Cat Food | 93% | Read Review |
| 4. Crave Cat Food | 93% | Read Review |
| 5. Nulo Cat Food | 93% | Read Review |
| 6. Earthborn Cat Food | 93% | Read Review |
| 7. Solid Gold Cat Food | 93% | Read Review |
| 8. Crafted Kibble Dog Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 9. WholeHearted Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 10. Vital Essentials Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 11. Simply Nourish Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 12. Stella Chewy’s Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 13. Farmina Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 14. Halo Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 15. Feline Natural Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 16. Soulistic Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 17. Fromm Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 18. Sheba Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 19. Organix Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 20. Canidae Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 21. I and Love and You Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 22. First Mate Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 23. Applaws Cat Food | 92% | Read Review |
| 24. Lotus Cat Food | 90% | Read Review |
| 25. Instinct By Nature’s Variety Cat Food | 90% | Read Review |
| 26. Dr. Elsey’s Cat Food | 90% | Read Review |
| 27. Meow Mix Cat Food | 90% | Read Review |
| 28. Redbarn Cat Food | 90% | Read Review |
| 29. Go! Cat Food | 90% | Read Review |
| 30. Wellness Cat Food | 90% | Read Review |
| 31. Purina ONE Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 32. Friskies Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 33. FreshPet Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 34. Acana Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 35. Purina Fancy Feast Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 36. Health Extension Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 37. Essence Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 38. Wysong Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 39. Kasiks Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 40. Natural Balance Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 41. Only Natural Pet Cat Food | 88% | Read Review |
| 42. Evolve Cat Food | 87% | Read Review |
| 43. Against the Grain Cat Food | 87% | Read Review |
| 44. Whole Earth Farms Cat Food | 87% | Read Review |
| 45. Authority Cat Food | 87% | Read Review |
| 46. Now Fresh Cat Food | 87% | Read Review |
| 47. Pure Vita Cat Food | 87% | Read Review |
| 48. Chicken Soup for the Soul Cat Food | 87% | Read Review |
| 49. Smalls Cat Food | 86% | Read Review |
| 50. Abound Cat Food | 85% | Read Review |
| 51. Wag Cat Food | 85% | Read Review |
| 52. Triumph Cat Food | 85% | Read Review |
| 53. Northwest Naturals Cat Food | 85% | Read Review |
| 54. Primal Cat Food | 85% | Read Review |
| 55. Tiki Cat Food | 85% | Read Review |
| 56. Orijen Cat Food | 85% | Read Review |
| 57. Darwin’s Natural Pet Products Cat Food | 84% | Read Review |
| 58. The Honest Kitchen Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 59. Hound & Gatos Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 60. The Real Meat Company Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 61. Ziwi Peak Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 62. Purina Beyond Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 63. Taste of the Wild Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 64. Iams Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 65. Purina Cat Food | 83% | Read Review |
| 66. Cat Chow Food | 82% | Read Review |
| 67. Nom Nom Cat Food | 80% | Read Review |
| 68. Hill’s Cat Food | 80% | Read Review |
| 69. Addiction Cat Food | 80% | Read Review |
| 70. Whiskas Cat Food | 80% | Read Review |
| 71. Young Again Cat Food | 80% | Read Review |
| 72. 9 Lives Cat Food | 78% | Read Review |
| 73. Royal Canin Cat Food | 77% | Read Review |
| 74. Rachael Ray Nutrish Cat Food | 77% | Read Review |
| 75. Blue Buffalo Cat Food | 75% | Read Review |
| 76. Purina Pro Plan Cat Food | 73% | Read Review |
| 77. 4Health Cat Food | 72% | Read Review |
| 78. Encore Cat Food | 70% | Read Review |
| 79. Cat Person | 68% | Read Review |
| 80. Encore Cat Food | 61% | Read Review |
How We Rank Cat Food Brands
Our Cats require a balanced diet in the same way that you do, but their nutritional needs are very different. As obligate carnivores, cats have a biological need for a high-protein diet and most of that protein should come from animal-based sources. That’s why we made our mission to responsibly review the top cat food brands on the market today to help you make an educate decision when shopping for cat food online
Our approach is that the more natural, whole-food ingredients, the better, and it should be complete and balanced with the help of vitamin and mineral supplements. We try to avoid recipes that contain low-quality fillers and by-products and consider the best food for cats to be high in protein with moderate fat content and low carbohydrate content.
Here are some of the other things we look for in a good cat food brand:
- High-quality animal protein as the first ingredient
- Rich in healthy animal fats (ex: chicken fat or salmon oil)
- Few to no carbohydrate ingredients (especially within the top 5)
- Limited number of main ingredients plus supplements
- No low-quality fillers, grains, or by-products
In addition to these requirements, we also look for cat food brands that offer a variety of different recipes for customers to choose from.
Cats can be picky eaters, so we think it is important for a cat food brand to offer a variety of products – having variety gives you more to choose from.
The brand’s recall history is a good way to gauge quality and safety as a whole while customer reviews provide insight into the brand’s quality and popularity.