9 Lives Cat Food Review
This page contains affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn More
When shopping for cat food, most pet owners are concerned about price. You don’t want to spend a fortune feeding your cat every month, but you need to be wary of brands that are too cheap – they’re probably made with cheap ingredients as well.
You’ve probably seen 9 Lives on the shelf at your local grocery store, or even the dollar store. This should give you a clue about the quality of the brand, but it’s still a good idea to take a closer look and do your own evaluation before making a decision.
Read on to see an overview of the 9 Lives brand and to see what we think of their products.
- Affordably priced
- Wide variety of choices
- Company isn’t particularly concerned with quality
- Includes unnamed meat or poultry ingredients and by-products
- Affordably priced
- Wide variety of choices
- Company isn’t particularly concerned with quality
- Includes unnamed meat or poultry ingredients and by-products
How We Review Cat Food Brands
When it comes to your cat, we know you want what’s best – that includes the best diet you can afford. The quality of your cat’s diet is directly related to its long-term health and wellness, so it is well worth paying a little more for your cat’s good.
If you’re wondering what makes a good cat food, you’ve come to the right place! We’ve tested, rated, and reviewed all of the top brands on the market. Before you check out our review of 9 Lives, there are a few things you need to know about your cat’s nutritional requirements.
Cats are obligate carnivores, so they have a biological need for a high-protein diet and most of that protein should come from animal-based sources. The best food for cats is high in protein with moderate fat content and low carbohydrate content.
Natural, whole-food ingredients are best, and your cat’s diet should be complete and balanced with the help of vitamin and mineral supplements. Avoid recipes that contain low-quality fillers and by-products.
Here are some of the other things we look for in a good cat food brand:
- High-quality animal protein as the first ingredient
- Rich in healthy animal fats (ex: chicken fat or salmon oil)
- Few to no carbohydrate ingredients (especially within the top 5)
- Limited number of main ingredients plus supplements
- No low-quality fillers, grains, or by-products
When reviewing cat foods, we try to be unbiased. Our goal is to provide you with a detailed overview of the company, a summary of the products they offer, and a closer look at some of the recipes.
Using this information, you can decide for yourself whether it’s the right brand for you and your cat.
Overview of the 9 Lives Brand
The 9 Lives company first hit store shelves in 1959, making it the first wet cat food brand in the United States. The brand set out with the belief that, “all cats deserve to live the good life – with good food, good health, and a good home.”
What started with a few formulas for wet food grew into a nationwide company that now offers four complete lines of products with both dry food and wet food recipes.
9 Lives is dedicated to giving cats the life they deserve – all cats. Not only do they offer a wide variety of cat food products, but 9 Lives and their spokes-cat Morris advocates for the adoption of rescue cats, working with shelters and donating both time and money to support the cause.
As we mentioned above, 9 Lives is available just about everywhere. You can find it on grocery store and dollar store shelves as well as in pet stores and online. This is easily one of the most affordable brands of cat food as well, which is both a good and a bad thing.
Low-priced cat foods are affordable and accessible to most cat owners, but you have to ask yourself whether they offer the best nutrition for your cat. As you’ll see in our recipe reviews below, 9 Lives’ low price comes from low-quality ingredients including corn, wheat, soy, and by-products.
Though 9 Lives offers affordability and variety, this brand is definitely at the lower tend of the scale when it comes to quality.
What Kind of Cat Food Products Do They Offer?
9 Lives offers dozens of different cat food products, though they specialize in wet food. This brand offers five different dry food recipes as well as four lines of wet food and several variety packs.
According to the 9 Lives website, their wet foods, “give cats the choice of tender, meaty morsels with rich gravy, flakes of fish, savory shreds, or ground cat food with flavor and aroma cats can’t resist.”
The majority of 9 Lives cat food recipes feature chicken or fish as the primary proteins. You’ll see several recipes that include beef or turkey as well as some mixed recipes that contain both poultry and fish. Choose from a variety of pates as well as wet foods in sauces and broths.
Here is the nutritional information for some of the most popular cat food recipes:
Dry Food Recipes
|Recipe||Protein %||Fat %||Fiber %||Moisture %||Calories (cal/cup)|
|Daily Essentials Dry Food||30||9||3||12||306|
|Indoor Complete Dry Food||30||9||4||12||305|
|Lean & Tasty Dry Food||31||8||10||4||299|
|Plus Care Dry Food||31||9||3||12||295|
|Protein Plus Dry Food||33||9||4||12||300|
Wet Food Recipes
|Recipe||Protein %||Fat %||Fiber %||Moisture %||Calories (can)|
|Meaty Pate with Real Liver & Bacon||9||5||1||78||165|
|Meaty Pate with Real Ocean Whitefish||9||4.5||1||78||159|
|Meaty Pate with Real Ocean Whitefish & Tuna||11||4||1||78||160|
|Meaty Pate with Real Salmon||9||4.5||1||78||160|
|Meaty Pate with Real Tuna & Shrimp||9||4.5||1||78||163|
|Meaty Pate with Real Turkey & Giblets||9||4.5||1||78||163|
|Meaty Pate Seafood Platter||9||4||1||78||170|
|Meaty Pate with Real Chicken||9||4.5||1||78||163|
|Meaty Pate with Real Chicken & Seafood||9||4.5||1||78||163|
|Meaty Pate Mixed Grill||10||5||1||78||167|
|Meaty Pate Poultry Supper||10||5||1||78||178|
|Meaty Pate with Real Beef (13oz.)||9||4.5||1||78||380|
|Meaty Pate Super Supper||9||4.5||1||78||168|
|Meaty Pate with Real Chicken & Tuna||9||4.5||1||78||168|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Chicken & Cheese in Gravy||8||2.5||1||82||123|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Beef & Chicken in Gravy||8||2||1||82||112|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Beef in Gravy||8||2||1||82||117|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Turkey in Gravy||8||2.5||1||82||115|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Chicken & Fish in Gravy||8||2||1||82||121|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Chicken & Salmon in Gravy||9||3||1||82||124|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Ocean Whitefish & Tuna in Gravy||9||2.5||1||82||123|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Turkey & Cheese in Gravy||9||3||1||82||134|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Chicken in Gravy||8||2.5||1||82||123|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Turkey, Chicken, & Cheese in Gravy||8||2.5||1||82||119|
|Tender Morsels with Real Ocean Whitefish, Tuna, & Cheese Bits||8||2.5||1||82||126|
|Tender Morsels with Real Beef in Sauce||8||2.5||1||82||115|
|Tender Morsels with Real Flaked Tuna & Cheese Bits in Sauce||14||2||1||78||139|
|Tender morsels with Real Flaked Tuna & Egg Bits in Sauce||14||2||1||78||139|
|Tender Morsels with Real Ocean Whitefish & Tuna in Sauce||9||2.5||1||82||123|
|Tender Morsels with Real Turkey & Chicken in Sauce||8||2.5||1||82||119|
|Tender Morsels with Real Turkey & Giblets in Sauce||8||2.5||1||82||120|
|Tender Morsels with Real Chicken in Sauce||8||2.5||1||82||118|
|Tender Morsels with Real Salmon in Sauce||8||2.5||1||82||128|
|Protein Plus with Tuna & Liver||12||4.5||1||78||160 kcal/cup|
|Protein Plus with Tuna & Chicken||12||4.5||1||78||160 kcal/cup|
Product Recall History
A product recall occurs when there’s an issue with the product or packaging. It sometimes happens when there’s concern about contamination, or it can be for something as simple as a labeling issue.
Having started in 1959, 9 Lives has over 60 years of history to cover when it comes to recalls. It wasn’t until the past two decades or so, however, that the FDA really started to take a closer look at pet food. Somewhat surprisingly, 9 Lives has only had 2 recalls in its history.
Here is an overview of 9 Lives pet food recalls:
- December 2018 (low thiamine levels) – The FDA issued a recall for 9 Lives affecting 4-can packages of Protein Plus canned cat food due to low thiamine levels.
- January 2017 (low thiamine levels) – This recall was issued for 4-packs and individual cans of four different recipes from the Meaty Pate product line.
Many pet food brands that experience recalls are those that outsource their production to other manufacturers. 9 Lives has the benefit of being a big enough brand that they have their own facilities – this may help with quality control.
Though the brand has only had two recalls in its history, you still have to consider the quality of the ingredients when you evaluate the brand as a whole.
Products Included in This Review
|Name||Type||Protein %||Fat %||Top 5 Ingredients|
|9Lives Daily Essentials with Chicken, Beef, Salmon Flavor Dry Food||Dry||30||9||Whole ground corn, chicken by-product meal, soybean meal, corn gluten meal, whole wheat|
|9 Lives Indoor Complete with Chicken & Salmon Flavor Dry Food||Dry||30||9||Whole ground corn, chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, soybean meal, whole wheat|
|Meaty Pate Mixed Grill Canned Cat Food||Wet||10||5||Meat by-products, water, poultry by-products, chicken, fish|
|Tender Morsels with Real Turkey & Giblets in Sauce Canned Food||Wet||8||2.5||Water, meat by-products, turkey, chicken, soy protein concentrate|
|Hearty Cuts with Real Beef in Gravy Canned Food||Wet||8||2||Water, meat by-products, beef, chicken, wheat flour|
This Daily Essentials recipe from 9 Lives is made with flavors of chicken, beef, and salmon. The package claims that it is 100% complete and balanced, formulated to support strong muscle growth, healthy heart & vision, and healthy skin & coat.
Unfortunately, the list of ingredients leaves much to be desired. Not only is whole ground corn the first ingredient, but you’ll also find soy and wheat ingredients listed within the top 5. In fact, chicken by-product meal is the only animal ingredient within the first 5.
No cat food that lists a carbohydrate (especially corn, wheat, or soy) as the first ingredient gets our blessing. It’s also worth noting that the estimated carbohydrate content of this formula is well over 30%. The only animal proteins are by-products or unnamed meat meals, aside from a little salmon meal.
This recipe also contains artificial colors and preservatives.
Taking a look at this Indoor Complete recipe, you’ll see that the first five ingredients are the same as the Daily Essentials recipe. In fact, the majority of the ingredients are the same with minor swaps like animal fat for beef fat.
Overall, this recipe appears to be primarily carbohydrate-based with limited amounts of animal by-products and unnamed meat meals. Though the crude protein level (30%) is perfectly adequate for cats, it is unlikely that the majority of it comes from animal products and none from quality ingredients.
In addition to questionable corn, wheat, and soy ingredients, this recipe also contains artificial colors and preservatives. We also see things like “animal digest” which are primarily used to flavor low-quality pet foods to make them more enticing for cats despite having lower meat inclusions.
Wet food makes up the majority of 9 Lives’ product line. This Mixed Grill canned food is made with flavors of chicken and seafood with a smooth texture.
Compared to the dry food recipes, this formula starts off a little stronger with four of the first five ingredients being animal-based. The trouble is two of them are by-products and three of them come from unnamed sources (meat, poultry, and fish).
Not only is this recipe full of unnamed ingredients and by-products, but it also contains questionable additives like carrageenan, artificial color, and a long list of synthetic supplements.
Many cats enjoy canned foods that contain sauce or gravy. This recipe is described as “real turkey and giblets that are smothered in a savory sauce.”
The trouble with canned cat foods that contain sauce is that they also tend to contain a lot of thickeners. This recipe relies on meat by-products, turkey, and chicken as the main sources of protein with cornstarch, wheat flour, and soy flour as thickening agents.
Though the majority of this recipe’s protein comes from animal sources, their quality is questionable. We also question the inclusion of artificial colors and an extensive list of synthetic supplements.
Many of 9 Lives products are made with a combination of different proteins, so we were curious to see how this beef recipe compared. We weren’t surprised to find that, while beef is included, it isn’t the first protein listed – this recipe also contains fish, chicken, and unnamed meat.
In comparing this recipe to similar recipes, we found the first 10 ingredients identical to those in the Hearty Cuts Real Beef and Chicken in Gravy recipe. There were only some adjustments in the order.
Overall, this beef recipe contains several sources of protein, most of which are animal-based. The problem is several of those sources are unnamed or by-products.
What Do Customers Think of 9 Lives Cat Food?
Using Chewy customer reviews as a foundation, it seems that most customers are pleased with 9 Lives. Ratings upwards of 4/5 stars are common, though some formulas achieve lower ratings of 3 stars.
When it comes to customer comments, many people love the low price. In fact, many of the positive ratings are based on price rather than the quality of the food – keep this in mind when you start shopping.
How Much Does 9 Lives Cat Food Cost?
Two of the qualities that make 9 Lives a popular brand are the variety and affordability. This brand offers just 5 different dry food recipes, but dozens of wet food formulas divided across four product lines.
9 Lives cat food is available in grocery stores, dollar stores, retail chains, pet stores, and online. With so many distributors, prices may vary but the brand as a whole is definitely at the lower end of the price scale.
Dry food recipes average about $0.65 per pound and most of the popular wet food formulas cost $0.8 per ounce. Certain flavors cost a little more, up to $0.14 per ounce.
To give you a better idea how 9 Lives stacks up against other cat food brands, here is a quick chart to show you some average prices for cat food:
|Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Food||Dry||Low||X||$0.90/pound|
|Friskies Classic Pate Mixed Grill Canned Food||Wet||Low||$0.07/ounce||$1.16/pound|
|Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Chicken & Brown Rice Adult Dry Cat Food||Dry||Moderate||X||$2.53/pound|
|Whole Earth Farms Grain-Free Real Chicken Pate Recipe Canned Cat Food||Wet||Moderate||$0.36/ounce||X|
|Instinct by Nature’s Variety Original Grain-Free Recipe with Real Chicken||Dry||High||X||$3.45/pound|
|Ziwi Peak New Zealand Venison Recipe Canned Cat Food||Wet||High||$1.21/ounce||X|
Where Can You Buy 9 Lives Cat Food?
Though 9 Lives may not be one of the absolute best brands on the market, it is certainly easy to find. You can find 9 Lives cat food everywhere from dollar stores and grocery stores to major retailers and chain stores.
Our Final Thoughts: Is 9 Lives a Good Brand?
Unfortunately, we can’t recommend 9 Lives cat food in good conscious. We love the fact that the brand is affordable and offers a wide variety of choices, but it is clear from our review that the company isn’t particularly concerned with quality.
Not only are many recipes very carbohydrate-heavy, but most make heavy use of unnamed meat or poultry ingredients and by-products. We also found it troubling that so many recipes were nearly identical in their ingredients list with simple tweaks to the order or the product name.
If you’re looking for an affordable brand of cat food but you aren’t willing to compromise on the quality of your cat’s nutrition, there are plenty of other brands to consider.