The 7 Best Tug Toys For Dogs

Dogs Reviews May 9, 2021
Written by | Updated Jun 13, 2021
Share Email Pinterest Linkedin Twitter Facebook
hyper tug toys

author:

The 7 Best Tug Toys For Dogs

This page contains affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn More

6 Best Tug Toys for Dogs

Many people think that tug games can lead to an increase in aggression and dominance in dogs. However, after years of research and observation experts found that when played correctly, a game that includes tugging can be a positive and great experience for you and your dog!

At a Glance: The Best Tug Toys For Dogs To Buy

We highly recommend looking at the comparison table we have below where we highlighted the features of each product. You’ll also find more detailed information about each product later in the article.

Compare Best Tug Toys For Dogs

Overall Best
AMZpets Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

1. AMZpets Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

Runner Up
Fire Hose Dog Tug Toy with Squeakers

2. Fire Hose Dog Tug Toy with Squeakers

Budget Pick
KONG Wild Elk Antler Dog Toy

3. KONG Wild Elk Antler Dog Toy

Best For Large Dogs
Jolly Pets: Rope and Ball Tug Toy

4. Jolly Pets: Rope and Ball Tug Toy

Best Durable
Chuckit! Tug Rope with Classic Rubber Balls

5. Chuckit! Tug Rope with Classic Rubber Balls

Best For Extra Large Dog
Pacific Pup Tug Rope

6. Pacific Pup Tug Rope

Best Lightweight
Nerf Dog Squeaker Vortex Chain Tug Dog Toy

7. Nerf Dog Squeaker Vortex Chain Tug Dog Toy

Price range
Mid-high
Price range
Low
Price range
Mid-high
Price range
Low
Price range
Mid-low
Price range
Low
Price range
Mid-high
Material
Cotton
Material
Firehose
Material
Naturally shed Elk antlers and cotton blend
Material
Cotton and rubber
Material
Rubber and two-ply nylon cord
Material
Cotton
Material
Nylon and stuffing
Size
3.79 pounds
Size
27 inches long, 3.2 ounces
Size
Available in two sizes
Size
1.81 pounds
Size
12 inches
Size
21 inches, 13.8 ounces
Size
30 inches long
Made In
China
Made In
China
Made In
USA
Made In
USA
Made In
Vietnam
Made In
China
Made In
China

There are many benefits to playing tug games with your dog. Tug games can also strengthen the bond you and your pup have! Playtime that includes playing tug-of-war provides an intense workout that engages all your dog’s senses. Not only is it a great physical workout but it stimulates their minds, too!

About Tug Toys

There are many different types of tug toys to choose from. When researching tug toys for your dog, you should consider your dog’s preferences for material, price, and durability. Tug toys should be soft to protect your dog’s mouth and teeth. Tug toys include some of the following:

  • Rubber “handle” tug toys: these types of toys are often made from a soft rubber material in an “s” shape.
  • Plush tug toys: These types of toys are great for smaller dogs or dogs with a low chewing drive.
  • Rope tug toys: Rope toys are knotted and twisted to create a strong tugging toy. These types of toys also act as dental floss, cleaning your dog’s teeth as he or she plays.

Tug Toy Safety Information

There are many different types of toys made by many different manufacturers. New toys should always be introduced with supervision. As a rule, you should monitor your dog’s interaction to ensure safety. Some toys should always be played with under supervision, for example, chews or bones. It is important to remember that no toy is completely indestructible. For that reason, you should periodically inspect your dog’s toys for signs of wear and tear.

Here are some guidelines to consider when conducting your own research.

Size: You should always choose toys that fit your dog’s size. Small dogs may not want to play with large toys, and small toys may be dangerous for large dogs.

Washability: Keeping your pup’s toys clean is very important. Always check to make sure that the toys can be machine washed, wiped down, dishwasher safe, or hand washed. This is critical in keeping your pup not only happy – but healthy!

Material: The material of the toy is very important. Dogs are driven by their strong sense of smell. Also, they love licking and tend to explore the world through their mouths. Since there are no federal regulations on dog toys, they can be made with almost anything. Thus, you need to make sure to do your research!

You know your playful dog the best, and know what types of toys he or she will like most. Your dog’s activity level – both indoor and outdoor, their ability and drive to destroy toys, and the size of your dog will help you figure out the best toys for them.

Guidelines To Follow When Playing Tug Of War

My 6-year-old Belgian Shepherd Malinois, Hyper, loves to play tug with his various toys. We have worked hard to encourage playful and non-aggressive tug games. Here are some of the guidelines we follow that have helped us ensure everyone is having fun!

Discourage growling or your pup showing his or her teeth. Discouraging can be vocal commands like “no growling” and stopping to play the game with your pup.
If your pup’s mouth or teeth touch you or your clothing, the game is over – even if it is an accident. This will teach your dog that under no circumstance is it ok for their mouth or teeth to touch you.

Teach your dog to release the toy (“drop it”) and sit on command. If your pup refuses, keep your hand on the toy but let your arm go limp and ignore your pup. Once they let go, shower them with positive reinforcements (treats and lots of “good boy/girl”).

Your dog’s tail will help you identify his or her feelings. A wagging tail means they are having fun!

How The Toys Were Tested:

  • We used our own money to purchase all the toys. In other words, the toys were not purchased in exchange for positive reviews.
  • Each toy was carefully chosen depending on quality, material, price range, and durability.
  • We spent a few hours each day testing the toys.

Our Top Picks For The Best Tug Toys For Dogs

Our dog LOVED this experiment, he was able to play and interact with so many new toys to create this list. In other words, Hyper has given all the items 5 stars and barking reviews!

The 7 best tug toys for dogs reviewed and compared:

Overall Best
1.

AMZpets Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

Product Info

  • Price range: Mid-high
  • Material: Cotton
  • Size: 3.79 pounds
  • Made In: China
Pros
  • Veterinarian Approved
  • 100% Cotton
  • Safe to use
Cons
  • Not recommended for overly aggressive chewers
  • Nondurable
AMZpets Large Dogs Toy Set is a set of 7 indestructible dog toys that will keep your dogs entertained for a while with all the different shapes and sizes for playing fetch, tug of war, or to endlessly gnaw or shake.

The ropes are made from high-quality chew toys and throwing ropes with knots. This is a safe, long-lasting dog toy that is great for games, fetch and play.
Runner Up
2.

Fire Hose Dog Tug Toy with Squeakers

Product Info

  • Price range: Low
  • Material: Firehose
  • Size: 27 inches long, 3.2 ounces
  • Made In: China
Pros
  • Made from real durable firehose material that is extremely hard to destroy
  • Three separate squeakers
  • No stuffing! You won’t need to clean up the stuffing if your pup destroys the firehose
  • Well made and cute designs
Cons
  • Always monitor your dog while playing with this kind of toy
  • Lizard legs can tear off (as seen in the photo)
Fire Biterz toys are made with durable tightly woven layers of the fire hose material. This lets your dog play as rough as he or she can with a toy made to withstand tons of pressure!

The toys are used for all types of playtime, including tug of war. Additionally, the Fire Biterz are not made with stuffing.

This means that if your pup DOES destroy it – because no toy is completely indestructible- there will be no stuffing thrown around your home. No. Stuffing. Thrown. Around. Your. Home! The squeakers also are durable, long-lasting, and will boost your dog’s playtime excitement.
Budget Pick
3.

KONG Wild Elk Antler Dog Toy

Product Info

  • Price range: Mid-high
  • Material: Naturally shed Elk antlers and cotton blend
  • Size: Available in two sizes
  • Made In: USA
Pros
  • Combines tug dependent play and independent chewing
  • Antlers are naturally shed
Cons
  • My pup is able to chew through antlers in record time – not for strong chewers
KONG has been in business since the 1970s. They are committed to creating healthy and durable toys for our furry friends. This unique tug rope has an elk antler attached to it! These antlers are tasty ways to satisfy your dogs chewing instinct and keep them busy for hours! This rope and antler are best for dogs that are less aggressive chewers.
Best For Large Dogs
4.

Jolly Pets: Rope and Ball Tug Toy

Product Info

  • Price range: Low
  • Material: Cotton and rubber
  • Size: 1.81 pounds
  • Made In: USA
Pros
  • All materials are recyclable and non-toxic
  • The ball is made from puncture resistant rubber
  • Acts as playtime dental floss for your pup
  • Great toy for tugging, chasing, and swimming activities!
Cons
  • Frayed edges may be torn off
  • The puncture-proof ball is heavy
Your dog will love this high-quality twisted and knotted rope with a puncture resistant ball looped through. It is tough and can withstand hours of playtime with your lovable pup. This toy is great for pups that like to play rough. The rubber ball comes in many different sizes, ranging from 4.4 inches to 8 inches. Because of the material and size of the 8 inch ball, it is over 1 pound! Hyper loves playing with this and swinging the ball around.
Best Durable
5.

Chuckit! Tug Rope with Classic Rubber Balls

Product Info

  • Price range: Mid-low
  • Material: Rubber and two-ply nylon cord
  • Size: 12 inches
  • Made In: Vietnam
Pros
  • High-quality materials
  • Compatible with the launcher
  • Balls are easily wiped down
  • Can be used in water and outdoor playtime
Cons
  • Active chewers may chew the strap
  • Active chewers may destroy the rubber balls
This ChuckIt! toy is a seamless crossover between playing tug of war and fetch! The high-quality blue nylon tug strap has two orange and blue rubber balls attached to each side. This toy is also compatible with the ChuckIt! Launchers, one of our ultimate favorite toys. It is great for families with one or more pups as they can play tug of war with their favorite ChuckIt! ball! The rubber balls are great to play with outside because they are easily detected and can be quickly rinsed off when dirty.
Best For Extra Large Dog
6.

Pacific Pup Tug Rope

Product Info

  • Price range: Low
  • Material: Cotton
  • Size: 21 inches, 13.8 ounces
  • Made In: China
Pros
  • Made from safe, non-toxic material
  • Passes the ASTM F-963 Children Toys Safety Standards
  • Proceeds help rescue dogs from high-kill shelters
  • Acts as playtime dental floss for your pup
Cons
  • Frayed edges may be torn off
Your dog will love this high-quality twisted and knotted rope. It is tough and can withstand hours of playtime with your lovable pup. Each purchase of these rope toys benefits a non-profit dog rescue called Pacific Pup Rescue. Pacific Pup Rescue helps rescue dogs from high-kill shelters and find them their forever homes. We love toys that support good causes. Without a doubt, this is a win-win!
Best Lightweight
7.

Nerf Dog Squeaker Vortex Chain Tug Dog Toy

Product Info

  • Price range: Mid-high
  • Material: Nylon and stuffing
  • Size: 30 inches long
  • Made In: China
Pros
  • The shape and material is really engaging
  • You can play fetch and tug games with this toy
  • It is lightweight but still durable
  • This toy is water-resistant, making water play so much fun!
Cons
  • Not made for strong chewers or tuggers – the football detached from the tail after a few days of play.
  • Hyper likes this toy so much that we have sewed it back together.
Nerf is a well known toy brand that also makes dog toys! There is something about this football vortex chain that my dog LOVES to play with. The football fits perfectly in his mouth, and he loves to shake the chain after playing. Unfortunately, this toy is not meant for aggressive chewers or strong tug-of-war players. I had mixed feelings about placing it on this list because the football detached from the chain, but Hyper loves it so much so we reattached it and here it is!

Final Thoughts

The best thing that we can do for our dogs is to challenge them, both physically and mentally, to keep them happy and healthy. I hope that you and your dog find this list of The 7 Best Dog Tug Toys for Dogs helpful and fun!

Was this article helpful?
Let us know what you think.

Avital lives in Los Angeles and enjoys exploring the outdoors with her pups!
One Comment
  1. Bily Bumer

    He destroyed every toy I bought. I have to try one of these. Thanks for the article!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *