The 5 Best Organic Cat Food

Cats Dec 22, 2019
Mallory Crusta
Written by Mallory Crusta | Updated Dec 10, 2020
Share Email Pinterest Linkedin Twitter Facebook
Best Organic Cat Food
Mallory Crusta

author:

The 5 Best Organic Cat Food

This page contains affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn More

Best Organic Cat Food

The best organic cat food would be worth buying whether it was organic or not.

That’s why we recommend Natural Planet Organics Turkey Dinner as the best organic cat food on the market. It’s USDA Organic certified and made with your cat’s carnivorous needs in mind. With a meat-first ingredient list, no carrageenan or other potentially-harmful additives, and plenty of moisture to keep your cat hydrated, it’s an all-around outstanding food.

Keep reading to learn more about this Natural Planet Organics food and our other top 4 recommendations. Before we jump into the reviews, though, we should talk about the makings of the best organic cat food.

At a Glance: Best Organic Cat Food To Buy

We highly recommend looking at the comparison table we have below where we highlighted the features of each product. You’ll also find more detailed information about each product later in the article.

IMAGE PRODUCT
  • Features protein-rich turkey and liver as primary ingredients
  • Doesn’t contain any common irritants or allergens
  • A USDA-certified organic food
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
  • Primarily made from organic chicken and liver
  • Certified organic by the USDA
  • Low carbohydrate content
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
  • Contains multiple sources of nourishing animal fat
  • Has guaranteed levels of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids
  • Primarily made from nourishing organic chicken
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
  • Formulated for growing kittens
  • USDA certified organic
  • Contains salmon oil as a source of the omega-3 fatty acid DHA
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
  • Contains only organic fruits and vegetables
  • Made with USDA edible-grade meat and produced in USDA-certified facilities
  • A meat-based food with plenty of nourishing animal protein
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

How Do You Choose The Best Organic Cat Food?

The best organic cat food is, well, organic. 

Only a few cat food producers use organic ingredients. Even fewer meet any standardized definition of being an organic food.

Some companies claim that their food is “made with organic ingredients”, indicating that the food is at least 70% organic. Just a handful are USDA certified organic. That distinction is exclusive to foods that are at least 95% organic.

When choosing the top 5 foods for this list, I looked for products that contained primarily organic ingredients and gave preference to those that had earned the USDA’s organic seal.

But that little green seal of approval doesn’t guarantee a great cat food.

Even if you assume that organic ingredients are better than non-organic ingredients—an assumption that isn’t always accurate—ingredient quality still isn’t enough. When choosing a food for your cat, nutritional composition is paramount.

Organic ingredients don’t make up for species-inappropriate nutrients. An organic sweet potato is still a bundle of carbohydrates that your cat doesn’t need.

That’s why the best organic cat food is made with carnivores in mind.

The best foods are more organic meat than organic veggies. They have plenty of protein, moderate levels of fat, and only the scarcest amount of carbohydrate matter.

From its moisture content to its fatty acid spectrum, every aspect of the best organic cat food is informed by your cat’s needs as a carnivore. That’s why all of the following foods are more than just organic products. They’re meaty and have minimal plant content. Most of them contain plenty of moisture to keep your cat hydrated in spite of his low thirst drive.

Best Organic Cat Food: Our Top 5 Picks

Overall Best: Natural Planet Organics Turkey Dinner Canned Cat Food Review

Product Info:

  • Protein: 10% Min
  • Fat: 9.0% Min
  • Fiber: 0.5% Max
  • Life Stage: All Life Stages
  • Type: Wet/Canned
  • Made In: United States

Pros:

  • Features protein-rich turkey and liver as primary ingredients
  • Doesn’t contain any common irritants or allergens
  • A USDA-certified organic food
  • Free of carrageenan, a potentially harmful additive common among organic cat foods

Cons:

  • Relies on multiple plant-based fat sources instead of animal fat
  • Lacks a large body of customer reviews to vouch for its quality

Natural Planet is an organic pet food line produced by the company behind NutriSource and Pure Vita. All Natural Planet canned cat foods are made with 95% organic ingredients and bear the USDA’s organic certification.

This Natural Planet recipe has virtually every quality we look for in cat food. It’s one of the few products that successfully combines organic ingredients with nutritional fundamentals. It delivers plenty of protein, avoids excessive plant ingredients, and doesn’t contain carrageenan or other potentially harmful additives.

With turkey muscle meat and liver as primary ingredients and nothing starchy, this is a meat-based, carnivore-appropriate recipe appropriate for cats of all shapes, sizes, and ages.

Best Budget: Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Organic Chicken & Chicken Liver Recipe All Life Stages Canned Cat Food Review

Product Info:

  • Protein: 9.0% Min
  • Fat: 5.0% Min
  • Fiber: 1.0% Max
  • Life Stage: All Life Stages
  • Type: Wet/Canned
  • Made In: United States

Pros:

  • Primarily made from organic chicken and liver
  • Certified organic by the USDA
  • Low carbohydrate content
  • Doesn’t contain carrageenan or other thickening gums
  • A popular, well-loved food

Cons:

  • Contains numerous plant ingredients

Realistically, there’s no such thing as cheap organic cat food. You’re always going to pay more for that organic certification. But if you’re looking for something on the economical end of the spectrum—think $3 rather than $4 a day—consider Castor & Pollux Organix. It’s been America’s number one organic pet food brand since 2003. Since 2017, every product in the line has been USDA organically certified.

This particular recipe is a paté-style canned food that bears both the USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project seals. Like so many foods targeting the premium niche, this food is loaded with a variety of organic plant ingredients like peas, coconut flour, and pea protein. None of these ingredients are necessary or particularly beneficial for cats.

The food’s carbohydrate content remains under 10% on a dry matter basis and meat heads up the ingredient list. All things considered, this is a moisture-rich, species-appropriate organic food option for cats.

Best Dry Food: Tender & True Organic Chicken & Liver Recipe Review

Product Info:

  • Protein: 30% Min
  • Fat: 18% Min
  • Fiber: 6.5% Max
  • Life Stage: Adult
  • Type: Dry
  • Made In: United States

Pros:

  • Contains multiple sources of nourishing animal fat
  • Has guaranteed levels of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids
  • Primarily made from nourishing organic chicken
  • USDA certified organic

Cons:

  • Low moisture content may contribute to urinary tract disease, particularly in male cats
  • High carbohydrate content

If you want to prevent urinary tract disease, avoid excessive carbohydrate matter, and keep your cat satisfied with fewer calories, wet food is the way to go. But for all the things wrong with it, there’s also a lot to like about dry food. It’s cheaper, more convenient, and more palatable for kibble-addicted kitties.

If you’re set on feeding organic dry cat food, consider this recipe from Tender & True. This company is focused on racking up certifications that validate its quality—certifications like the Global Animal Partnership’s Step 3 certification for humanely-raised chicken and the USDA’s organic certification.

The food is a grain-free product that features organic chicken and chicken meal as primary ingredients, served up alongside a variety of starches and legumes. Like most dry foods, it’s high in carbohydrate content and is not a particularly species-appropriate diet for your obligate carnivore.

Best for Kittens: Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Organic Kitten Recipe Review

Product Info:

  • Protein: 9.0% Min
  • Fat: 7.0% Min
  • Fiber: 1.0% Max
  • Life Stage: Growth
  • Type: Wet/Canned
  • Made In: United States

Pros:

  • Formulated for growing kittens
  • USDA certified organic
  • Contains salmon oil as a source of the omega-3 fatty acid DHA
  • Low carbohydrate content

Cons:

  • Contains several plant ingredients

This food from Castor & Pollux Organix is one of the few products that is both USDA-certified organic and formulated specifically for the needs of growing kittens. While you can safely feed your kitten any food that’s either approved for “growth” or “all life stages”, this food is among the few organic-label products that are marketed just for kittens.

This food is USDA certified organic and certified by the Non-GMO Project. Each batch is cooked in an organically certified US kitchen.

As a kitten food, it has slightly more fat than other foods from Organix. It places an emphasis on DHA, an omega-3 fatty acid essential for brain and eye development.

Though it’s ultimately a meat-based food, the recipe contains some plant ingredients. These include pea protein, coconut flour, and peas, none of which are nutritionally necessary for your tiny carnivore.

Best for Sensitive Stomach: Primal Turkey Formula Nuggets Grain-Free Raw Freeze-Dried Cat Food Review

Product Info:

  • Protein: 57% Min
  • Fat: 23% Min
  • Fiber: 2.0% Max
  • Life Stage: Adult
  • Type: Freeze-Dried
  • Made In: United States

Pros:

  • Contains only organic fruits and vegetables
  • Made with USDA edible-grade meat and produced in USDA-certified facilities
  • A meat-based food with plenty of nourishing animal protein
  • Contains multiple sources of anti-inflammatory fatty acids
  • Uses a single protein source, making it ideal for cats with digestive issues

Cons:

  • Not a certified organic food according to the USDA’s standards
  • Primal foods have been recalled several times

This food doesn’t earn the USDA’s organic certification, but it does have a few outstanding qualities. If you want to feed your cat highly-digestible raw food with organic ingredients, this Primal recipe is one of the best options you have.

Like all Primal foods, this recipe contains only certified organic produce. The ingredient list includes organic collard greens, organic squash, organic pumpkin seeds, organic kelp, and more. Primal products don’t contain synthetic supplements. Instead, they rely on this array of organic fruits, vegetables, and other plant ingredients as food-based nutrient sources.

Though the food’s poultry ingredients aren’t organic according to the USDA’s standards, they come free of antibiotics, hormones, and steroids. Primal adds that the meat, organs, and bones are taken from vegetarian-fed animals raised on ethical, sustainable ranches.

Click here to learn more about Primal’s quality standards.

Though the food contains a colorful variety of organic fruits and vegetables, it’s far from a plant-heavy food. It’s made with turkey muscle meat, necks with bone, hearts or gizzards, and liver as its primary ingredients. For cats with food sensitivities and potential food allergies, this single-protein recipe may help to identify or resolve intolerances.

The Best Organic Cat Food Is Great, But So Is The Best Non-organic Cat Food.

Limiting yourself to organic cat food is a great way to miss out on a world of excellent products. There’s no guarantee that organic food is any more responsibly-sourced than non-organic food, nor is it any more nutritious. In most cases, organic cat foods are even more veggie-packed than their non-organic counterparts.

Some of the best cat food on the planet is not organic—at least according to the official definitions established by the USDA and other organizations. Many of those non-organic foods feature high-quality ingredients that were humanely and sustainably harvested. From ingredient quality to nutritional value, there’s a wealth of non-organic foods that just might be worthy of your cat’s bowl.

Want to go beyond organic cat food? Explore our recommendations.

Mallory Crusta

Mallory Crusta is a blogger and adventurecat enthusiast who brings you the facts about cat products, wellness, and care. She's the co-founder of Wildernesscat, a resource for savvy cat guardians who want to give their felines richer, healthier lives. Visit Wildernesscat for product reviews, radically natural nutrition tips, and lifestyle inspiration
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *